How to make a Legal Citizen's Arrest

Prepared by Lee Street Management
PP

By law a citizen's arrest can be made under the following circumstances:
Any person may arrest without warrant anyone who is in the act of committing an arrestable offense or suspected of being in the act of committing such an offense.

Where an arrestable offense has been committed any person may arrest without warrant anyone who is guilty of of the offense or suspected of being guilty of it.

An arrest is not to be considered lightly since it is effectively restraining someone from his or her liberty. You do not have a duty to arrest someone, but you do have the power to do so. You can can decide whether or not to exercise that power and if you choose not to use it you are not committing an offense.

It must however, be proved that the suspect intended to commit theft and that he/she appropriated the property with the intention to permanently deprive the owner of it. So you must be sure that the person has knowingly taken the goods from your premises with no intention of paying for them or returning them. If you have no doubt that a crime has been committed, then you have the power to make an arrest.

The following checklist of important rules has been compiled with the help of local police and law enforcement officials.
 
  1. You must see the person take an item of personal property and attempt to leave the premises without permission or without paying. Make sure they still have the stolen property on their person and they have not passed it to an accomplice or discarded it in fear that you have been watching them.

  2. You must maintain uninterrupted surveillance. For example, if you suspect thief or other category of criminal passed behind fixtures or other visual obstructions, or in any way goes temporarily out of your sight, do not proceed with the arrest.

  3. Approach the suspect and identify yourself. For example: "I am the owner of that....property," then state positively a set phrase, such as "You have taken an item for which you have not paid. Will you please return to the premises with me."

  4. When you stop a suspect, do not use force unless it is absolutely necessary. Section 3 of the Criminal Law Act states that you are entitled to use "reasonable" force to arrest someone. But the word "reasonable" is highly debatable. The deeper your pockets, the more highly debatable that word becomes.

  5. When returning to the premises, you should walk slightly behind the suspect making sure that the thief does not attempt to discard the item.

  6. On return to the premises, call the police immediately. Allow them to conduct the interview. DO NOT try to interview the suspect yourself.

  7. If possible have a witness present at all times, particularly if a male member of staff is arresting a female suspect of vice versa. A simple, but false counterclaim can turn a good arrest into an opportunistic thief's windfall.

  8. Keep the suspect under constant supervision to prevent him or her from harming themselves or someone else and to prevent disposal or destruction of evidence. If two or more persons have been arrested, keep them apart and out of sight from each other until the police arrive.

  9. Under no circumstances should you search the suspect. Your can ask them to turn out their pockets or bags, but if they refuse to do so, do not carry out the search yourself, even if they invite you to do so.

  10. When the police arrive tell them exactly what happened. Do not exaggerate or elaborate. After the police have taken the suspect into custody, make thorough notes of everything that happened, including what the person, and the police said to you, then sign the notes with the date and time. Get any witnesses to review the notes and sign them too.

  11. Treat all suspects with consideration and respect at all times.
The rules for other types of crimes are essentially the same. Just be aware that if your suspect has committed a crime of aggression or violence, you are at a much higher risk of danger. It is possible that the arrest could escalate into a severe confrontation, perhaps resulting in serious physical injury. Unless you are quite capable of such confrontation or you perceive the crime so henious that allowing the suspect to escape is unthinkable, be prepared to let him or her get away. Call the police immediately.
PRINT THIS LIST                                          CLOSE THIS WINDOW